I wouldn’t trade you for another

Happy Mothering Sunday! I hope y’all got up nice and early to steal flowers, scribble in cards and cobble together breakfast for the one that made you. Sadly, my Mummy Dearest is thousands of miles away, across oceans and mountains, so I’ve had to try and think of another way to show my love.

As any regular reader will have realised, TV is never far from my thoughts. TV is PCP’s religion, after all. So, as I thought about all the things I loved about my mother, all the things that made her so fab, I began to think about the multitude of small screen mums that weren’t so lovely and fab. For every apple-pie-making Marion Cunningham, there’s at least 10 mothers who would make out with your boyfriend/best friend or serve you arsenic pancakes. Not that I’m complaining – bad mothers make for goood tv.

So, Mum, here are 10 TV mothers that make me love you more than ever! (I certainly wouldn’t trade you for another – not even for Mrs. Cunningham.)

Susan Delfino, Desperate Housewives

You can’t swing a cat in Wisteria Lane without hitting a bad mum. There’s murderesses, terrorists, baby-stealers, alcoholics, child-abusers… but Susan takes the cake. (Which she would totally burn to a crisp, of course.) Her biggest parenting crime is to rob her daughter of a childhood. Poor Julie is forced to serve as bemused confidante as the codependent Susan parades an endless stream of unsuitable lovers and gets into scrapes around the neighbourhood, falling naked into bushes and whatnot. After Julie successfully flees the nest, Susan moves a hooker into the family home. It’s not the presence of young son M.J. that pushes her to rethink the inapropriate living situation but the possibly wandering eyes of hubby Mike. And then there’s the webcam career

Isobel Flemming-Saltzman, The Vampire Diaries

Isobel couldn’t help being a gym-slip mum. In fact, giving daughter Elena up to her babydaddy’s brother and wife, the loving and wealthy Gilberts, may have been one of the best things she’s ever done. Even deliberately becoming a vampire is somewhat understandable, in light of her scholarly pursuits. What is less forgivable is her continuing interference in Elena’s life, especially her attempt to engineer the deaths of the Brothers Salvatore, one of whom is Elena’s boyfriend. Lady, you gave up her up – now back off.

Beverly Hofstadter, The Big Bang Theory

Leonard’s psychiatrist-neuroscientist mother has an acid tongue and stony heart. She’s stingy with hugs, but free with humiliation and unwanted crippling insights – it’s no wonder Leonard tends to be clingy and neurotic in his romantic relationships.  She’d rather share important family developments – like death and divorce – with Leonard’s similarly cold and analytical flatmate Sheldon.  As well as make out with him when drunk.

Shelby Corcoran,  Glee

Where to begin with Rachel’s birth mother? After incubating the little songbird in exchange for a fat paycheck, Shelby signed a contract promising to wait until Rachel turned 18 before seeking her out. Unable to wait another year or so, she employs her probably gay star student to woo Rachel and get her to listen to a tape of her singing “I Dreamed a Dream” from Les Miserables. However, when Rachel manages to figure it all out, Shelby decides she can”t be a mum after all. She wants the baby she gave up, not the young woman Rachel has become.  So she scoops up the lovechild of Rachel”s main romantic rival and ex-makeout buddy and disappears into the sunset, with nairy a care for her first daughter’s crushing sense of abandonment. All the star-patterned beakers in the world couldn’t make up for such a cruelly whimsical approach to motherhood.

Evelyn Bass, Gossip Girl

Chuck Bass’s playboy ways make perfect sense when you consider his troubled parentage. His late father was distant and critical, and he never knew his mother, who died in childbirth. Or so he thought.  While visiting his father’s grave, he spies a mysterious woman leaving flowers. She leads him on a wild goose chase, before finally conceding that she is his mother, and was paid by his father to stay away from him. In the end though, it turns out Chuck was far better off thinking she was dead. After worming her way into his heart, she sells him out – and his company – to her secret lover: his Uncle Jack.

Dede Pritchett, Modern Family

Dede Pritchett is the queen of passive aggression. Her kids Claire and Mitchell are on constant edge in her presence, convinced that she’s always scheming to ruin their lives. Dede delights in gifting Mitchell’s cuddly husband with a salad spinner and sharing tales of Claire’s wilder days with her grandchildren. She took things a stage further by inviting Claire’s high school sweetheart to dinner and proceeded to hook up with him on the doorstep! But there’s nothing passive about her attitude to Gloria, her ex’s new and much younger wife – most of their encounters end in a one-sided catfight.

Patty Hewes, Damages

Patty Hewes’ take-no-prisoners approach, so essential to her success as a high-stakes litigator, carries over to her personal life. When she fell pregnant early in her legal career, she forced a miscarriage by doing everything the doctor said she shouldn’t.  Once married, she led her husband to believe he was the father of her son Michael, whom she goes to extreme ends to control. She has his much-older (and pregnant) girlfriend arrested for statutory rape, and he retaliates by trying to kill her. Even her mother-daughter-like relationship with protegee Ellen Parsons takes a dark turn when she (unsuccessfully) arranges the younger woman’s death to avoid being found out for a fatal act of blackmail.

Betty Francis, Mad Men

Betty Francis – nee Hofstadt, formerly Draper – is the picture of perfection, a cool blonde and a consummate ice queen. She regards her increasing brood as burdens, and is alternately dismissive and cruel towards them, shutting them in closets and shoving food down their throats. When her daughter Sally is devastated to learn of the death of her grandfather – the only adult who has ever shown an interest in her – she offers no sympathy, instructing her not to be “hysterical” and to “watch TV”. Her bad mothering makes sense in light of what we gradually learn about her unhappy childhood, and we sympathise further as we watch her (now ex-) husband Don embark on a series of affairs and equally ignore their kids. But it doesn’t make it alright, or any easier to like her. Among the many Mad Men, pretty Betty is the No. 1 Crazy Lady.

Ellis Grey, Grey’s Anatomy

As much as I hate to speak ill of even the fictional dead, Dr. Ellis Grey put Meredith through the  wringer. Her affair with Richard Webber – later Meredith’s Chief of Surgery – results in the end of her marriage and her daughter’s lifelong estrangement from her father. Meredith was particularly traumatized by an incident in which she witnessed her mother slit her wrists in a desperate attempt to win her lover’s attention. Their relationship is further complicated when Ellis develops Alzheimers. She mostly failed to recognise Meredith- and in lucid moments, she expressed a grave disappointment in her surgeon daughter for being “ordinary”. However, she managed to make some amends from beyond the grave. When Meredith was near death herself, Ellis appeared to her as a spirit and told her she was “anything but ordinary”. But was it too little, too late?

Lettie Mae Thornton, True Blood

Bon Temps is crawling with monsters – and some of the worst are simply human. Tara endured a terrible childhood thanks to her mother’s violent brand of alcoholism.But when Tara encountered addiction problems of her own, culminating in jail for drunk-driving, Lettie Mae – jumping on the born-again bandwagon – refused to bail her out, leaving her vulnerable to a so-called social worker’s supernatural manipulations. Lettie Mae’s later attempt at reconciliation almost results in Tara’s suicide, as she’s too focused on seducing a married reverend to notice her daughter’s fragile state of mind and continuing grief over the brutal death of the only man she’s ever loved.

10 thoughts on “I wouldn’t trade you for another

  1. Oh gosh, there’s so much terrible mothering on TV, it’s made me a little angry! I totally agree with your picks, but am now fighting the urge to somehow crawl into the small screen so I can slap some sense into this lot…
    Still, like you said, it does make you appreciate the good ones 🙂

    • Michael seems a bit…diabolical. Learnt behaviour from his mumma! Sally’s definitely more likeable than he is, she also seems to have picked up unpleasant traits from her mother but she seems more genuine.

  2. I still can’t forgive Betty, even learning more about her. Mum’s aren’t meant to be selfish! She’s so mean to Sally! Okay, Don ignores the kids too, but Betty seems to actually dislike them a lot of the time, and is putting her kid in therapy just so she has someone to talk to. ARGH it makes me so mad!

    Can we do a list of awesome TV mums? I’m having trouble thinking of any, honestly. Real life Mums RULE.

    Only cool TV mum I can think of is Joyce Summers…I forgive her for that whole MOO thing…

    • Betty is a horrible mother, but I do feel for her a bit. She’s so naive in her way.

      Fo shizzle we should have a list of good mums too, to cheer us up if nothing else! Maybe we should have a brainstorming session?

    • What’s MOO? We should definitely do awesome mums, you volunteering? Hehe. The US Mother’s Day is in May, I think. My mum always insists on celebrating both.

      • Mothers Opposed to the Occult- from the Buffy ep where the creepy demon kids stir up hatred against magic, and Buffy and Willow’s mothers try to burn them at the stake. Possibly NOT the kind of behaviour we should encourage for US Mother’s Day!

  3. Pingback: Mommie Dearest « Pop Culture Playpen

  4. Pingback: World’s Greatest Dad « Pop Culture Playpen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s